The Second Commandment (not to be confused with the Second Amendment,
which it supersedes – and perhaps even countermands)--the Second Commandment,
of the big Ten from that tablet Moses brought down from Sinai way back when,
says, “You shall not make any graven image, in the form of anything in heaven or on
the earth, and you shall not bow down to such things and worship them.” (Exodus
20.4-5, Plumbley translation). Pretty strong. Pretty direct in ordering our relationship
to all created things. Right? Well, it's not so easily kept!
The first time I was in the Holy Land I was younger than my older son is
now. I was thoroughly Protestant in regard to “holy” things, which is to say I was
pretty much appalled at the notion of tangible holiness, or holiness in things that are
made and can be destroyed. Holy people I understood. Holy relics, holy spots, holy
objects, not so much. I remember being taken aback by the whole notion of an entire
land that bore the title “Holy.” And when I arrived there I remember being irked—no,
really offended—the first time I saw someone get down on her knees, bend forward
and kiss a spot in the floor which someone said covered a place something special in
the Bible had happened.
Nine of us just returned last Wednesday from Israel. It was a great trip, full
of important, interesting and enjoyable relationship-building, marvelous sights to see,
and wonderful people to see and meet. Yet Israel is, at one and the same time, both the
most religiously inspiring and religiously problematic land on earth. There are more
places to point to and say “something wonderful once happened here” than perhaps
any other place on the planet. That, in itself, makes it a dangerous place—and I don't
mean dangerous in the sense that some terrorist might try to kidnap you, I mean dangerous
in the sense that one is tempted to idol worship.
Forgetting altogether the unreliability of claims a thing or event actually happened
in any particular spot two or three millennia ago, there is a deeper theological
problem at work. Holiness is an attribute of God, and God is not locatable. God cannot
be trapped in a box, stone, log or building. God is not ever to be identified with a
piece of wood, a rock, the sun, the moon, a body of water, a building. Our source of
security and our ultimate allegiance is never a piece of cloth, a document, a weapon,
or any other thing, place or system. That Second Commandment makes that pretty
darn clear.
All that notwithstanding, it is undeniable that all of us have fond memories
that are connected to objects, places and people. Sometimes this “fondness” can even
take on qualities of sacredness. This is particularly true when the object, place or person
is associated with something we believe to be an act of God or a time of God's
palpable presence or particularly evident grace. In such a case the object, place or person
may become dear to us. We may properly take action to preserve or protect it (or
them). It (or they) may become a part of our story of God's work in the world. But it
(or they) must never become god for us, and we must never behave in a manner toward
it (or them) that is reserved only for God.
This is why we do not bow before human beings. It is why we do not kiss
stones or paintings or flags or sticks of wood. It is why we grieve, but we do not venerate
our relatives when they die. And it is why we are able to move on when great
changes happen to very dear things and places. It is because God is God, and none of
these lesser things. And we trust the dynamic, living God of all creation to continue to
act, to continue to move, to continue to bring life in new people, in new places, even
in us!
I'll see you and your guests under the dome Sunday. Remember to share rides
when possible, to wash your hands often, and to share the love of God always, even if
only with a smile. To prepare for Sunday, please read 2Cor. 5.16-21.
Peace, Tom